The Never Released Debate I Lost to Matt Fradd

Published 5 hours ago

6 years ago, while I was Protestant, I debated Matt Fradd on Sola Scriptura. Here's the full debate!

💸 Want to support CC? https://capturingchristianity.com/donate/

✨ Free books! https://tinyurl.com/CCFREESTUFF

📱 Business inquiry? http://capturingchristianity.com/contact/

0:00:00 Introduction
0:05:03 What the Catholic Church Teaches About Scripture
0:08:05 Defining Sola Scriptura (Peckham's Three Prongs)
0:14:52 Where Do You Draw the Line?
0:20:33 The Self-Refutation Objection
0:22:07 Cameron's Biblical Case for Sola Scriptura
0:25:29 2 Thessalonians 2:15: "Hold to the Traditions"
0:27:26 Three Beliefs We Hold by Tradition, Not Scripture
0:31:09 Is There a Verse That Teaches Sola Scriptura?
0:38:35 Circularity and the Canon
0:40:14 Cameron Makes a Concession
0:43:48 Is Peckham's Version Self-Refuting?
0:47:29 2 Timothy 3:16: The Proof Text?
0:50:23 "I Want to Be Wrong About This"
0:51:27 Fradd's Case: Unhistorical, Unbiblical, Unreasonable
0:56:52 Cameron's Rebuttal: Interpreting the Interpreter
1:02:42 Denominations, Schism, and Disunity
1:08:43 Q&A Begins
1:09:41 Material vs. Formal Sufficiency
1:11:35 Is Sola Scriptura a "Blueprint for Anarchy"?
1:15:12 Fradd: "That's a Really Interesting Objection"
1:16:14 Matthew 18: "Tell It to the Church"
1:21:13 Can We Trust Fallible Humans?
1:23:56 When Did Public Revelation End?
1:26:29 Fradd's Closing Statement
1:28:41 Cameron's Closing Statement
1:34:38 Wrap-Up