Season two's "Eye of the Holder" ended in a way almost no case does: the demon left the victim and took one of the men holding him down. In this debrief, Ryan Bethea presses Fr. Carlos Martins on the mechanics of that night. Why Father Wyatt trusted his team. Why Gary said yes to a last-minute call he had no business accepting. What confession actually requires, and what it does not. Why a demon that has been in the room for hours suddenly starts calling a volunteer “hot stuff.” And the answer to the question the audience has been asking for a year: what happened to Gary.

Thanks to our Sponsors:

Right now, save up to 20% on mattresses and up to 25% on everything else when you go to https://Casper.com.

Head to https://forkfulmeals.com/EXFILES for 50% off your first order today! Use promo code Exfiles

Head to https://Exodus90.com/exfiles and start your 14 day free trial. Seek the Lord...see what happens!

Get 15% off OneSkin with the code EXFILES at https://oneskin.co/EXFILES #oneskinpod

Timestamps
0:00 Cold Open: The Cracked Photographs
0:45 Back Into the Most Frustrating Case of Season Two
1:31 “A Failure Worthy of Tolkien”
2:39 Why an Exorcist Won't Hear His Own Team's Confessions
5:25 How Do You Scare a Team Without Terrifying Them
7:05 The Goof Named Gary
9:02 The Mortal Sin in the Room
12:16 Shame, and Why Confession Is Not a Deposition
14:16 Sponsor Break: Casper and Forkful
18:05 The Brilliant Deception: “Just Go Serve God”
18:57 Would Contrition Alone Have Cleared Him
20:49 Forgiven and Still Not Ready
22:52 Emergency vs. Scheduled: “Tuesday at 11 a.m.”
25:04 The Houston Foyer
26:46 Did Father Wyatt Ask? On Trusting a Vetted Team
28:33 Rolled Case Audio: “Hot Stuff”
29:35 Sponsor Break: Exodus 90 and OneSkin
33:05 Why the Room Missed It
35:57 Justin: Abandonment, a Gang, and a Blood Oath
38:42 Peons and Generals: Leviathan Takes the Room
40:44 The YouTube Demonologists
42:29 The Moment: Rolled Case Audio
43:58 Demons Don't Jump
45:50 Rolled Case Audio: “Renounce the Affair”
46:38 Why Gary Is Harder Than Justin
48:10 A Powerlifter in Full Manifestation
49:16 He Walks Out, and St. Joseph's Rod Breaks in Three
51:12 The Million-Dollar Question: What Happened to Gary
52:16 “Gary's Name Is Not Gary”
52:36 Who Belongs in the Room
53:57 The Morals, and the Man Who Died in the Wrong Bed