BREAKING: Sam Shamoun Has NOT Converted to Catholicism? – The Evidence Considered

Did Sam Shamoun really convert to Catholicism? In this in-depth episode, I carefully walk through the evidence, claims, and public statements surrounding Sam’s religious identity and whether he has actually entered full communion with the Catholic Church. This isn’t about accusations—it’s about clarity.

We look at Sam's own words, Church law, the process for reception into the Catholic Church (Latin Rite and Chaldean Catholic), and what the Vatican says about Eucharistic sharing with Eastern and non-Catholic Christians. If Sam is claiming to be Catholic but has not formally converted to the Catholic Church, should he be open about that? Should he be teaching?

00:00 Sam opened the door to this question
01:34 Evidence I converted to Catholicism in 2012
05:01 I'm just asking questions, not accusing Sam
05:35 Sam claims he converted to Catholicism
07:36 Sam's religious background and the Assyrian Church of the East
09:37 Sam claims to be Catholic and a Catholic apologist
12:20 Sam's followers are saying he isn't fully Catholic
13:49 What Sam had to do if he has converted to Catholicism in the Chaldean Catholic Church
19:20 Eastern Orthodox can receive the Eucharist- and they aren't Catholic!
20:21 What Sam had to do if he has converted to Catholicism in the Latin Rite.
22:46 Vatican Guidelines to the Eucharist for the Assyrian Church of the East
24:59 Canon 844.3 on Eastern Orthodox receiving the Eucharist
25:53 Canon 844.4 on Protestants receiving the Eucharist
27:16 Does Sam think he is Catholic because he receives the Eucharist?
28:41 Will Sam produce receipts if he has converted to Catholicism?
29:39 Catholics are entitled to know if Sam has not converted to Catholicism
30:40 Sam should not be teaching by his own admission
31:25 Non-Catholics are entitled to know if Sam has not converted to Catholicism
31:50 Why is Sam calling out Catholic apologists like Jimmy Akin and Paul Thigpen?
34:56 Why is Sam calling out Catholic apologists like Alex from Voice of Reason?
36:34 Sam calling me to "come back home" and Jason Charron's hit piece video
38:39 My time in Eastern Orthodoxy
39:20 Has Sam been up front with his audience about this issue?
40:40 Sam, show the paperwork and date of your alleged conversion!
42:33 How Sam and his followers will likely respond
44:48 Sam has blocked me so I can't respond to him directly
45:20 Sam doesn't actually watch my response videos when he responds
46:07 If Sam can show he has formally converted, then great!
48:10 Sam owes an explanation to his patrons and followers
48:48 Catholics and non-Catholics are tearing Sam's apologetic material apart

📖Answering Orthodoxy: https://shop.catholic.com/answering-orthodoxy-a-catholic-response-to-attacks-from-the-east/
🎓Courses: https://www.rtcourses.com/
💰Go Fund Me: https://gofund.me/e12bf94e
💰Donate: https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=WV79VFBBXCEBE
👪Patreon: patreon.com/reasonandtheology
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/themichaelloftonshowrt/
Store: https://rtmerchstore.com/
Twitter: https://x.com/ReasonTheology

DON'T FORGET TO SUBSCRIBE AND LIKE!